First: this guide is informational
This text explains the broad outline of the available remedies. Deadlines and procedures change; always check the information on the website of the body concerned, and consult a lawyer or a legal service for a specific situation. It is not legal advice.
Which law, which body?
The answer depends on who is involved and where they are. In Canada, several regimes coexist:
- A private business in Quebec: Law 25 modernizes Quebec's private-sector privacy law. The oversight body is the Commission d'accès à l'information (CAI).
- A Quebec public body (ministry, municipality, health establishment, university…): the CAI as well.
- A private business in the other provinces, or one that moves data between provinces or abroad: PIPEDA, overseen by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada (OPC).
- A federal institution (agency, department): the federal Privacy Act, also overseen by the OPC.
- Alberta and British Columbia have their own private-sector laws and their own commissioners; Ontario and other provinces have special regimes for health and the public sector.
If in doubt, start with the OPC or the CAI: a body contacted by mistake can point you to the right one.
Step one: write to the organization
Before filing a complaint, you are generally expected to try to settle the problem with the organization. In Quebec, businesses must designate a person in charge of the protection of personal information, and that person's title and contact details must be published on their website. That is who to write to.
Your letter or email should contain:
- your contact details and, if possible, a customer or file number;
- the facts, with dates: what happened and when you found out;
- what you are asking for, precisely: access to your information, correction, deletion, an end to a use, an explanation of a breach;
- a reasonable deadline to answer (laws often set 30 days for an access or correction request);
- a mention that you may go to the oversight body.
Keep everything: the letter, proof of sending, the replies, screenshots. An email or a registered letter leaves a trace.
If the answer is unsatisfactory or missing
In Quebec: the CAI
Two procedures must be told apart. The request for review of a disagreement targets the refusal of an access or correction request, or no answer at all: the deadline to file is generally 30 days after the refusal or after the response period expires. The complaint targets a practice that, in your view, breaks the law (excessive collection, disclosure without consent, a poorly handled incident). Check the forms and deadlines on the CAI website (cai.gouv.qc.ca).
Federally: the OPC
The OPC handles complaints about private businesses covered by PIPEDA and about federal institutions. As a general rule, the complaint must be filed within a year of the event, although the Office may accept a later filing in some cases. You file online or by mail on the Office's website (priv.gc.ca), free of charge.
What the body can and cannot do
- It can investigate, ask for documents, attempt a resolution and issue findings or recommendations.
- In Quebec, Law 25 provides for administrative monetary penalties (up to 10 million dollars or 2% of worldwide turnover) and higher penal fines (up to 25 million or 4%): these are ceilings, for serious cases.
- A commissioner generally does not award damages to the person who complained. To be compensated, you need a court action.
The civil remedy
In Quebec, the law lets a person whose rights were infringed obtain damages, including punitive damages when the infringement is intentional or results from gross fault (the law sets a minimum of $1,000 in punitive damages in that case). Class actions are common after large breaches. For a modest amount, the Small Claims Division of the Court of Québec is a route open without a lawyer, within its ceiling. A lawyer can assess the best route, and some offer a free first consultation.
Example of a request to the organization
Subject: request for access to my personal information and explanation of an incident. Hello, on [date], I received a notice saying my information had been exposed. Under the applicable law, I ask you for: 1) the list of information about me that you hold; 2) the circumstances of the incident and the measures taken; 3) confirmation that information you no longer need has been deleted. Please reply within 30 days. Otherwise, I will turn to the competent oversight body. Sincerely, [name, contact details].
Adapt this template to your case. The more precise your request, the harder it is to answer beside the point.
Tips for a solid complaint
- Be factual and chronological; avoid unsupported accusations.
- Attach the evidence: screenshots, emails, confirmation numbers, a copy of the privacy policy in force at the time.
- Say clearly what you want to obtain.
- Respect the deadlines: act as soon as you notice the problem.
- Keep an up-to-date file with every exchange.
In short
Write to the person in charge within the organization, then go to the CAI or the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada as appropriate: the process is free, and a well-documented file beats a long story. To understand your rights before starting, read our article on the right to be forgotten and the glossary of privacy terms.