An email that watches you back
You open a newsletter, a promotion or an email from a telemarketer. Without clicking anything, the sender can know that you opened it, at what time, how many times, with which device and roughly from where. This is done with a tracking pixel (or web beacon), a common email marketing technique.
How it works
The pixel is a tiny image, often one pixel by one pixel and transparent, inserted in the HTML code of the email. Its address contains an identifier specific to your message. When your email software loads images, it downloads this one from the sender's server. The server logs the request:
- the identifier, so who opened which email;
- the time and frequency of opens;
- your IP address, which gives an approximate location;
- information about your device and software (system, email app).
The tracking is often paired with tracked links: a link's address first goes through the sender's server, which notes your click and then redirects you to the real page.
A concrete example: you get “Your cart is waiting” from an online shop. As soon as the email displays, a pixel tells the shop that you read it, at what time and from which network. If you click, the link carries an identifier that ties it to your customer record. You did nothing but read.
Why it is a privacy issue
- Your reading behaviour is measured without your knowledge.
- The message identifier can be linked to your profile at the sender and combined with other data.
- Some players use it for targeted prospecting, or even to confirm that an address is active before reselling it or targeting it with fraud.
- Your approximate location leaks through the IP address.
In Quebec, Law 25 requires a business to inform people when it uses a technology that can identify, locate or profile them. In practice, this tracking is rarely explained clearly in a marketing email.
What the big services do (and do not do)
- Apple Mail offers “Protect Mail Activity”: it preloads images through a relay, which hides your IP address and distorts open measurement.
- Gmail goes through an intermediary server (proxy) that hides your IP address, but the sender can still know the email was opened. You can also choose not to display images automatically.
- Thunderbird and several email clients block remote content by default.
Settings change from one version to the next: check those of your app.
How to protect yourself
- Block automatic loading of remote images. This is the most effective step. In Gmail, choose “Ask before displaying external images”; in Apple Mail, turn on Protect Mail Activity; in Outlook, turn off automatic image download.
- Read in plain text the emails from unknown senders: no HTML, no pixel.
- Use a client that respects privacy or an email service that strips trackers.
- Unsubscribe from newsletters you no longer read (using the official link, never one from a suspicious email).
- Use email aliases for sign-ups: you cut the link with your main address and can disable an alias that becomes invasive.
- Add a network layer: a VPN hides your IP address, but does not block the pixel itself.
How to check whether an email contains a pixel
Almost every marketing email has one. To see for yourself, open the message's source code (an option in the “Show original” or “View source” menu, depending on the app) and look for <img tags sized 1 by 1, or whose address contains a long string of random characters. A newsletter's links also often go through a tracking domain rather than the sender's own: hovering over a link shows its real destination.
Legitimate and abusive uses
A pixel is not always malicious. An organization may measure how many people read its newsletter in order to improve it, in aggregate form and openly. The problem appears when the tracking is individual, unknown to you, tied to a profile or resold. If you send newsletters yourself, respect your readers' privacy: state the measurement in your privacy policy, avoid collecting more than necessary and offer a simple unsubscribe.
The limits
Blocking images stops the pixel from loading, but not tracking through links: by clicking, you signal your presence. And some emails lose their layout without their images. It is a trade-off: choose a setting that suits you, and display images case by case for senders you trust.
In short
The tracking pixel is invisible, but not unavoidable: blocking remote images by default solves most of the problem. To go further in protecting your inbox, read our email security guide, and see how this kind of tracking fits into the wider picture with the browser fingerprint check.